WiiLoaded.com - Wii Forum and News

Full Version: Graphic Rating
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.

ssbb_lover Wrote:
Bad sig tbh, but the animation makes it +2 and it looks very clean. Steady 8/10. Big Grin

Rate both of these please and thank you. All critic is extremely appreciated.





*EDIT*

As Byuakuya said, that Naruto one stands out very well. I like it a lot, though there's 0 lighting. haha. 7.5/10 (only down .5 Toungue )


The background of the animated one doesn't look so good I know that but it was just hard for me to get a good one >.< but still thats a good rating Big Grin

And I added some lighting in the Naruto one >.< look at the older one...
and sorry i can't rate your sigs i'm not that good at rating >.>

I said ALL critic is welcome, Wiiloadian. Smile I don't even care if you give me a 4/10, if I see some critique I see and agree with, i'll gladly use it in the future.

In other words: RATE THEM OR FOREVER BE ON MY ENEMIES LIST.


Big Grin

ssbb_lover Wrote:
Bad sig tbh, but the animation makes it +2 and it looks very clean. Steady 8/10. Big Grin

Rate both of these please and thank you. All critic is extremely appreciated.





*EDIT*

As Byuakuya said, that Naruto one stands out very well. I like it a lot, though there's 0 lighting. haha. 7.5/10 (only down .5 Toungue )


I'm not a fan of the first sig.
The light source is too hard, make it so you can only see half the circle and move it to the left a bit. (move it up, and to the left in short)
The background just looks like a mess, can't see any flow at all.
I don't notice any depth...
I say just scrap it =/

The second sig is pretty nice, although I believe the red lighting coming from the gun is a bit off, (I'm talking about how its radiating on Dead Pool's arm and leg, just doesn't look right)
Also needs a border.
I think you mentioned a white border.. but just make it black.

I agree with you, thanks Rawr. ^_^ Tell your bro to feel free critiquing me, even if he doesn't think he's good at it. I welcome all comments.

New sig in the making, i'm liking the outcome atm. Big Grin Will post when done.

ssbb_lover Wrote:
Rate both of these please and thank you. All critic is extremely appreciated.



Something about this makes me want to vomit. Don't ask me why. hehe. Kinda...busy? it's just a lot of randomness. Like I've said before. if there's one thing I get, it's flow. (even if I can't pull it off myself).... the pen work on the right is good, but the left detracts a bit. Soften the light while making it a bit larger...it barely even shows.



I'm liking the softer bg...but it's a little "simple" lolz. The text needs help imo. Neither the render or the bg warrant such a "techy". And even so...it's still a bit basic. And I know you're trying for the "edgy" thing with the text colors..but it kinda detracts IMO. Myself, I don't have a problem with the lighting in this one...I kinda like it. Toungue Keep the whole gun gray too.


Good thing using the GIMP doesn't impair my ability to critique sigs brutally.

Just be safe in knowing that if you feel bad about my critiquing, I'll be putting out a new sig you can rip apart. w00p w00p

Rawrmander Wrote:
I don't notice any depth...


I fail to see how you can't notice "any depth". The render stands more than the bg, it has a focal, and what's around the focal is blurred. How can't you notice the sig's depth??

My latest tag:




Oh and I have a massive and AWESOME!!! collection of stocks (300+) in my PB account. Hope this helps someone..

http://s153.photobucket.com/albums/s212/...07/Stocks/

Enjoy Big Grin

My current avatar what I wanted it to be.... The animation's jerky cause I deleted some frames to lower the quality. but it's still 158 in the smallest form.



@DF

don't like the border at all. The left and right sides of the bg are well blended and lighted, but they don't look right. The left is "spikey" while the right is "bubbley". Yeah, I usually pride myself on my usage of the English language, but I cannot express my feelings toward that background in any clearer words.

oh, and the girl always helps.

I usually don't like sigs that are tall and skinny.

Brawny Wrote:
@DF

don't like the border at all. The left and right sides of the bg are well blended and lighted, but they don't look right. The left is "spikey" while the right is "bubbley". Yeah, I usually pride myself on my usage of the English language, but I cannot express my feelings toward that background in any clearer words.

oh, and the girl always helps.

I usually don't like sigs that are tall and skinny.


Alright. Wink

Whaddya think bout this ?

lol its ... meh alright...
^ Its not that bad, but I don't really like the black and whiteness it should have some more colours. i give it a 6.5/10

My 2 latest sig, the second one is pretty bad (that's what I think)

The first one has no focal point... u need to make it focus on the render...

2nd one is over contrasted...

this pleases

((made on Gimp))
Change the colors and it could kick ass, too bad there's two focals.
back online i see
cc on this please
8/10 wow the depth is awesome!

how do i get the flames more realistic on the tank?
Bump ^^ (this is dead)

anyways...

just keep trying nd ull get it Ieu... ^_^]]
Nyahhhhhhhhh , no one is using this this thread no mores ... -_0;
Most people are too busy with school then sig making a suppose.
*shrugs*
permission to make a new thread like this ? *crosses fingers*

^_^
What is the point of creating a new thread just the same as this one?

Is it going to automatically make everyone stop doing school work and concentrate of giving critque?

Dont worry, soon it will pick up again.
=0


yeah i see your point...


i just like hearing feedback... ^_^
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6
Reference URL's