WiiLoaded.com - Wii Forum and News

5 Reasons Not to Buy a DSi (But Why I Probably Will Anyway)

Last week Nintendo announced a new iteration of their highly successful DS handheld and, while many mainstream outlets had a field day, the response from the gaming community – and, for that matter, the Japanese stock market – was a resounding "huh?!"

With the impending release of this system upgrade being something of an open secret, it wasn't so much the device itself that seemed to cause the head-scratching as it was the odd specifics of its new features and the strange direction in which Nintendo elected to present it.

This newly christened DSi is an obvious member of the DS family, with its stylus and minimalist clamshell design, but Nintendo would seemingly like us to believe that it is a wholly different animal.

Even amid insistence that the system has a place alongside the DS Lite on American retail shelves, at least for the foreseeable future, I’ll wager that many, like me, can’t help but wonder if this device will prove to be the new face of mobile gaming. And, if so, wouldn’t it be prudent to get onboard early?

Well, I guess that depends on how these new features stack up. Let’s take a look, shall we?

    1 How about the camera? The most highly touted modification to the DSi is the inclusion of two – count ‘em: two – digital cameras. In addition to the one visible on the exterior of the unit, the DSi also boasts a second camera on the inside of the system continually pointed at the player. Sadly, these cameras weigh in at a scant .3 megapixels, and pictures are saved at a mere 640x480 resolution. So, while it might be fun to warp and scrawl atop your pics via the touch screen, it’s doubtful whether the image quality of your DSi photographs will be superior to those taken with the camera already integrated into your current cell phone. [EDIT: While several sources have reported that the DSi cameras were both 0.3 megapixels and others said 3 megapixels, Electronista has cleared up the confusion: the interior camera is a 0.3 megapixel VGA camera, while the external camera is a 3 megapixel.]  

   2 What about the bigger screens? Of more interest to gamers is the increased screen size of the DSi. Its 3.25 inch diagonal screen width stands out as a noticeable increase from the 3 inches of its predecessor. However, despite this enhanced physical real estate, the screens are virtually indistinguishable from a technical standpoint, as the DSi still boasts twin TFT LCDs of identical resolution to those of the DS Lite. You can, however, expect these bigger screens to burn through your valuable battery charge at an increased rate.

    3 What about backwards compatibility? While the screens are larger -– requiring an increase in system length and width –- the DSi is slightly thinner than the DS Lite. It is of note that this slim-down comes at a cost: in this case the removal of that old standby the GBA cartridge slot. (Yes, this means add-ons like that the knuckle busting fret board attachment for the recent DS Guitar Hero title will be incompatible.) Instead the DSi features an SD card slot in addition to the standard DS game cartridge slot.

    4 Will it play MP3s? One purpose of the addition of this SD slot is that the DSi will also act as a music device. Notice that I said music device and not MP3 player. Rather than MP3 playback, the handheld will instead support AAC files. While the AAC file type is often described as having superior sound quality to the ubiquitous MP3, it certainly lacks its familiarity. And while the addition of functionality like speed and pitch control for songs sounds interesting, it’s also doubtful that the machine will be replacing your iPod when it comes to music playback.

    5 So what can I download? The system also features on-board flash memory for use in storing titles procured from the newly revealed DSi Shop. This little brother of the current Wii Shop channel will likely have both the strengths (the potential for lots of interesting new titles as well as for a backlog of games from earlier systems) and the weaknesses (slow rollout and a lack of sufficient demos) of its older sibling. So, while you’ll be able to play these new offerings as well as your current collection of DS titles on your DSi, all DS/DS Lite owners will really be missing out on is the downloadable love.

All things considered, the DSi seems to be a mixed bag. It certainly adds some functionality, but much of it appears mediocre at best. Picture and music support seem incidental as opposed to integral, and info concerning features like superior sound quality and the promised integrated web browser seem scarce. (And, as anyone who’s used the app can corroborate, saying that the browser will be superior to the original DS Browser cart is dubious praise.)

From Nintendo’s insistence that the system will be the company’s "third platform" –- a role previously filled by the recently abandoned GBA -– to statements like those of NOA’s Cammie Dunaway to our own Game Life blog in which she announced that the DSi would continue in the tradition of Nintendo’s handhelds by not being region locked … maybe … even the Big N seems a little unsure why we should be excited about the product. And yet, for some reason, I am.

In recent years Nintendo has taken to revamping systems with features that should arguably have been integrated from the get-go, and summarily wowing us with their newest flavor of shiny plastic. And, at least with regard to their handheld lineup, the trick has been working. There are gamers out there chomping at the bit to hand the company money for devices that, in one form or another, they already own. I know this to be true because I am such a gamer.

I was an early adopter of both the original DS and the DS Lite, not to mention its forerunner the Gameboy Advance. Hell, I even imported a GBA SP just to get it a few months before the North American release. To my mind, I do this not because I’m a totally rabid Nintendo fanboy (although that’s an accusation I’ve faced in the past) but merely because I’m an avid gamer-on-the-go with a unique love for Nintendo’s robust portables. Even when they’re slightly less robust than I’d like.

So now, after this lengthy diatribe about how the DSi may well not be worth the $180+ they’ll be asking for it on American shores, I will admit to you that I’ll probably buy one anyway.

As a fan of Nintendo, a handheld gamer, and a gadget guy, I simply can’t resist the allure of new plastic.

source

I think Nintendo has made a big mistake by not making both cameras at least 3 megapixel, or if they wanted a lower end camera, it should have been put on the inside.  I also don't like the fact that the system will not play MP3 and yet has gone for the AAC format.  All that being said, I'm sure the system will sell well, and we can all hope that this isn't a piece of transition technology until the true DS 2.0 comes out.

1. the camera. 3.0 MP is better then a lot of high quality cell phones on the market TO DATE. 0.3 mp on the interior... thats kinda sad but still the exterior itself is worthy of praise.

2. The screen size and battery life was already talked about. of course battery life would die a lot faster. i assume Nintendo will most likey handle this before release if NOT, then later along the line.

3. Ok GH DS is the only game that I can think of that wouldnt be BC. Any others? Besides GH DS isnt the same calibur as GH on console.

4.iPod replacement nah, did the PSP replace the iPod? what would make you think the DSi could? This just shows that Nintendo is finally branching off to other mediums in the gaming market like Sony and Microsoft did. Its called progress my friend.

5. what can you download, i would think that players will be be able to download some of the Wii Shop channel games except the possibly N64 [unless otherwise] plus GBA/GB/GBC games! GBA/GB games alone are huge libaries. On 4gb memory cards? Imagine how many game you would be able to fit?



nice read but DSi is still a worthy upgrade to buy, but isnt a successor yet. not at all.

I was hoping the DSi would be released in Europe before next year because I badly need a replacement for my broken DS Lite. Sadly, we all know that's not going to happen, I need a new DS ASAP; so I'll be buying a Red DS Lite. Maybe I'll pick up a DSi at some point as well.

seems like an incremental improvement at best

probably get it anyway...sigh

I'll get it. My DSLite is crapping itself anyway.

Want a camera. Winnage.

Why is everyone so upset about the GBA port gone? I just do not understand, I do for games that actually utilize it. But idk, i always felt it a waste unless I was playing PKMN. But it was there just in case I needed it.

but some people dont see the fact that this could be a excellent thing here, we have a SD card. The DSi could be updated with firmware. there is a DSi Shop channel. So those GBA games you missed out on or couldnt find, will be on your SD card!

meh, just me.

I bet Nintendo doesn't allow it, heck... half of the flashcards don't work apparently. However (hopefully) it won't take long to override any crappy Nintendo firmware updates to make them functional.

I mean Hell, they do it for the Wii. (LOVE HOMEBREW)

The only problem I have with it (and why I won't buy it for a while but I will eventually because I collect Nintendo systems and games) is because it can't play Gameboy Advance games. I play Gameboy games probably 50-50 on my DS (whose battery is going broke, it only works a couple of hours now it seems) and I think it is a big, big mistake for Nintendo to take it out.



And now that I think of it, does anybody else see the problem with all these "enhancements"? Why did Sega lose console wars? No games for one, but because they came out with too many systems. Even though everyone will probably buy the DS 3 times, it seems like a waste of Nintendo's time when they could be focusing more on future systems, and that is why I think people are losing faith in Nintendo. They have shifted from doing one thing really amazingly at a time to tons of tiny things at once and it is slightly affecting their quality.