This post was last modified: 09-02-2008 09:21 PM by wiiman360.

1. No flow, renders are not blended. You pretty much only did, was make a bg, and add renders to it. 3/10
2. Better, no depth, bad text, althought I like the text position. 4.2/10
3. Bad text overlay and text. No flow. 4/10
4. Same as above.
5. Same as #1.
6. Good at banners. But no effects. 7/10
7. One word: Simple. 4/10
8. Good flow, barely any depth. Flat. 6/10
9. Good, but maybe add a render.....6.4/10
10. Same as #7.
11. Good render blending, bad text, most depth you had yet, but it's not enough, but work on the flow a bit more. 6.3/10
12. Um....I don't think you understand what C4D's are used for....*not rated*

Overall: Beginner

Sorry, but it looks like you just began/haven't had enough experience with PhotoShop just yet.

I've been doing this for awhile. I only used photoshop on #11 the reast are photodraw which doesn't give you much. I really want to learn photoshop. Thanks for that and i'm surprised that the banner scored the highest.

*There are 13 photos not sure y you did only 12*

This post was last modified: 08-14-2007 09:28 PM by wiiman360.

*bump*
srry bout dble post

I've increased on my sig making ability! yay!

*bump again*

i've added more and i think im gettin better

can u rate on my new ones to se if i've gottin better

This post was last modified: 08-30-2007 09:41 PM by wiiman360.

Haven't added some in a while and was wondering if you could rate mine now:

I'll rate them. They're much better than your first ones, and have some awsome effects added to them.
1: pretty nice, like the smuddging, needs more color though
2: Sonic is pretty blured, which looks cool, but you don't follow through with shadow
3: The numbers should be a bit larger, but not too large, just a size or two bigger, Looks nice otherwis
4: Text should be darker or the backgroud lighter, maybe a bit of both, doesn't have a main part to the sig
5: Looks nice, again, text should be darker or the background lighter, and the ft look nearly invisable. Looks nice though.

thanks ill take ur comments into consideration

wow this is old i havent made sigs and what not in FOREVER